| Platinum | Guanataco |
| Gold | Pollo Salsa |
| Silver | Taco's Azteca |
| Bronze | Eva's Mexican Food & Taqueria |
| Top Pick | Casa San Miguel De Allende |
| Top Pick | Don Juans Romantic Mexican Food |
| Top Pick | El Paisano Tortilleria |
| Top Pick | El Viejon Seafood & Bar |
| Top Pick | LA Patrona Authentic Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Monterey's Little Mexico |